Zadie Smith Reading and Topics for Discussion
Last night I attended a reading by Zadie Smith at Bryn Mawr College. Ms. Smith is a wonderful reader. She adds accents to her characters’ dialogue, which enriched the time spent.
What I was most impressed with was the question and answer session. When asked her opinion of the spread of multiculturalism and where it’s going, she retorted (and I’m paraphrasing) that multiculturalism isn’t something that can be boxed or policied or compartmentalized. It is a natural progression of a global society. The moment humans were able to cross an ocean and climb into a plane the blending of cultures and ethnicities was destined. In other words, it just happens.
I also thought it was interesting when another audience member said that she thought Ms. Smith’s characters were vivid and truly represented entire groups. Ms. Smith’s retort (again paraphrasing) was that characters shouldn’t represent an entire group but stand on their own as representing the individual character and nothing more. If one character seemed to represent an entire ethnic or religious group then those are the sections of text in which the writer has failed.
What are your opinions regarding these topics? I’ll save mine until I receive some responses to this post.
What I was most impressed with was the question and answer session. When asked her opinion of the spread of multiculturalism and where it’s going, she retorted (and I’m paraphrasing) that multiculturalism isn’t something that can be boxed or policied or compartmentalized. It is a natural progression of a global society. The moment humans were able to cross an ocean and climb into a plane the blending of cultures and ethnicities was destined. In other words, it just happens.
I also thought it was interesting when another audience member said that she thought Ms. Smith’s characters were vivid and truly represented entire groups. Ms. Smith’s retort (again paraphrasing) was that characters shouldn’t represent an entire group but stand on their own as representing the individual character and nothing more. If one character seemed to represent an entire ethnic or religious group then those are the sections of text in which the writer has failed.
What are your opinions regarding these topics? I’ll save mine until I receive some responses to this post.







3 Comments:
Hi Lisa,
I am afraid I differ with Zadie on the first point. To say that multiculturalism in a globalized world is imminent, is to disregard the political and sociological weight of the term. Multiculturalism in Europe is coming under a lot of strain because it purportedly promotes hostility among the immigrant communities for their host countries. This is the crux of Michael Barone's argument in The New Americans which I recently reviewed for Philly. It argues for assimilation as a remedy for immigrant rage. Zadie's response seems to be borne in a rather utopian notion that destinies of different faiths get entwined solely because they share the same geographical space. They may get destined, but not for good.
I, however, agree with her second statement. Characters in novels must never become tools to promote any given agenda. They must be developed as individuals with the weight of history and society fully impinging on them, and tracking their development through this maze. I think an author can make a truly assertive point only when (s)he allows his/her characters to live out the consequences of their actions rather than become propagandist in tone.
By
Vikram Johri, at Wednesday, September 20, 2006
On the topic of multiculturalism, I believe that the exchange, evolution, and blending of cultures is indeed inevitable That does not mean, however, that changes and assimiliation should come at a complete loss of individual cultural identity.
As for Ms. Smith's comments on characters, I'd have to say that I feel good characters are in fact a combination of both individual stand-alones, and representatives of a greater whole. For example, if I read about a character who is a total geek, I'm going to identify with that character from a personal standpoint, and see elements of that character in my geeky kindred. But that character, if well written, will also have unique qualities which stand apart from myself others of my ilk; as Vikram states, they should "live out the consequences of their actions."
Great questions - thanks for sharing. It's been a while since I was read to... but it's so much fun, isn't it?
Jade
By
JLB, at Thursday, September 21, 2006
hey vikram johri,
you kept a blog till a few days back. i cant find that site anymore. not that link which opens through your mug. it had a piece on Pamuk's My Name Is Red. i cant find it anywhere now. i also saw it on some irish website a few days back. i'm doing a paper on orhan and wanted to read that article again.
pls if you read this (i mailed you twice) send it to kara.kitap@gamebox.com. i need that brilliant piece urgently.
By
kara, at Wednesday, January 17, 2007
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home